Course Guide: We visit a completely new venue on the PGA Tour this week – Caves Valley Golf Club. It’s a Tom Fazio design which has hosted a few high profile professional events, including the 2002 Senior U.S. Open. On the LPGA in 2014 it hosted the International Crown team event and as recently as 2017 hosted the Constellation Senior Players Championship on the Champions Tour, won by Scott McCarron.
Caves Valley Golf Club, Owings Mills, Maryland: Designer: Tom Fazio, 1991 with Logan Fazio 2020 renovation; Course Type: Resort; Par: 72; Length: 7,542 yards; Number of Holes with Water In-Play: 5; Fairways: Penncross Bentgrass; Rough: Tall Fescue, Kentucky Bluegrass and Perennial Ryegrass 3″; Greens: 5,200 sq.ft average featuring Pure Distinction Bentgrass; Stimpmeter: 12.5ft.
Widths Fairway Widths (yards): Below are the fairway widths for Caves Valley Golf Club and how they compare to recent courses on Tour:
- Caves Valley: 25-28 yards.
- Liberty National: 250 yards from tee: 37 yards wide; 275:33; 300:30 325:31; 350:27.
- Sedgefield: 250 yards from tee: 29 yards wide; 275:28; 300:26 325:23; 350:22.
- TPC Southwind: 250 yards from the tee: 29 yards wide; 275:29; 300:28; 325:31; 350:25.
- Old Greenwood: 35-40 yards.
- TPC Twin Cities: 250 yards from the tee: 38 yards wide; 275:38; 300:31; 325:30; 350:36.
- TPC Deere Run: 250 yards from tee: 41 yards wide; 275:40; 300:36 325:33; 350:30.
- Detroit Golf Club: 250 yards from tee: 34 yards wide; 275:34; 300:35 325:34; 350:33.
- TPC River Highlands: 250 yards from the tee: 38 yards wide; 275:36; 300:29; 325:29; 350:28.
- Torrey Pines South: 250 yards from the tee: 26 yards wide; 275:27; 300:25; 325:24; 350:23.
- Colonial: 250 yards from tee: 27 yards wide; 275:26; 300:27; 325:26; 350:23.
- Ocean Course – Kiawah Island: Up to 50 yards wide.
Course Designer Links: For research purposes, other Tom Fazio designs include:
- Atunyote GC – 2007-10 Turning Stone Championship.
- Conway Farms GC – 2013, 2015, 2017 BMW Championship.
- Corales GC – Corales Championship
- Eagle Point – 2017 Wells Fargo Championship
- Raptor Course Greyhawk GC – 2008/09 Fry’s.com Open.
- Shadow Creek Golf Course – 2020 CJ Cup.
Fazio has also had re-design input into:
- Merion – 2013 U.S. Open.
- Oakmont – 2016 U.S. Open.
- Quail Hollow – 2016, 2018, 2019, 2021 Wells Fargo Championship & 2017 PGA Championship.
- Riviera Country Club – Genesis Invitational.
- Seaside Course at Sea Island – RSM Classic.
Course Overview: Caves Valley Golf Course is an 18 hole, private golf facility located 15 miles northwest of Baltimore, Maryland. The Tom Fazio design, as you would expect, has been consistently ranked as one of the top courses in the state of Maryland and the Mid-Atlantic region. In the hills of Maryland, the reversed tournament layout (this week will see the sets of 9 reversed) features a front 9 which is wooded with plenty of elevation changes. The back 9 is pretty flat, features more water and also features plenty of long Fescue grass for the wayward.
Ultimately though when comparing Caves Valley to Liberty National last week, this course features tighter fairways, although there are fewer problems off the fairway and greens which are 600 sq.ft on average larger. All 4 of the par-5s are sub-600 yards, whilst the par-4s are an interesting mix. It’s rare that you see 3 par-4s at sub-400 yards on the PGA Tour, but here at Caves Valley, the 1st (365 yards), 5th (356 yards) and 11th (356 yards) must look enticing to the longer players in this field. At the other end of the scale though, there are 6 par-4s which measure over 450 yards.
4 par-3s look like a difficult proposition, with the scorecard highlighting 224 yards (3rd), 223 yards (6th), 221 yards (13th) and 192 yards (17th). So par-3 scoring and approach play from +200 yards looks a good route to explore for this particular course.
It’s a guessing game as to just how difficult Caves Valley will play this week, but a look at the 2017 Constellation Senior Players Championship shows to me that we are likely to see another low scoring affair. Caves Valley is no Olympia Fields which hosted the BMW Championship in 2020, which in essence was a Major Championship venue which featured firm and fast conditions for the most part. And although it’s a 7,500+ yard, Par 72, distance alone won’t bother the best golfers in the world.
At the Senior Players Championship, the course that week played as a 7,196 yard, Par 72, so in effect just under 400 yards shorter than we will see this week on the PGA Tour. Winner Scott McCarron, who ranked 2nd for Driving Distance, won with a winning score of -18/270 by a single stroke from Brandt Jobe and Bernhard Langer at -17/281.
Winners: 2020: Jon Rahm (-4); 2019: Justin Thomas (-25); 2018: Keegan Bradley(-20); 2017: Marc Leishman (-23); 2016: Dustin Johnson (-23); 2015: Jason Day (-22); 2014: Billy Horschel (-15); 2013: Zach Johnson (-16); 2012: Rory McIlroy (-20); 2011: Justin Rose (-13); 2010: Dustin Johnson (-9).
Tournament Stats: We’ve published some key player statistics for this week’s event that are well worth a look. Naturally they’ll help to shape a view on players who could go well this week, although as noted this year’s renewal is at a new venue: Current Form | Tournament Form | First Round Leader | Combined Stats.
Published Predictor Model: Our published predictor is available here. You can build your own model using the variables listed on the left hand side. Top 10 of my published predictor are Jon Rahm, Dustin Johnson, Bryson DeChambeau, Justin Thomas, Xander Schauffele, Webb Simpson, Brooks Koepka, Daniel Berger, Cameron Smith and Tony Finau.
Winners & Prices: 2020: Jon Rahm 10/1; 2019: Justin Thomas 16/1; 2018: Keegan Bradley 140/1; 2017: Marc Leishman 45/1; 2016: D Johnson 10/1; 2015: Day 15/2; 2014: Horschel 66/1; 2013: Z Johnson 40/1; 2012: McIlroy 7/1; 2011: Rose 66/1; 2010: D Johnson 33/1. Past 7 Renewals Average: 42/1; Overall Average: 40/1.
Weather Forecast: The latest weather forecast for Caves Valley GC, Maryland, is here.
We move to 200 miles south-west to Baltimore, Maryland for this week’s BMW Championship and the weather should be far more settled. Think hot (33-34 degrees Celsius), still conditions and a golf course which took on 68mm of rain last week. Watered greens would seem a requirement in this heat, so I expect the typical BMW -20 or below scoring this week.
Recent Player Strokes Gained Rankings: These top 25 in the field rankings are based on an 8-tournament window that stretches back to the Rocket Mortgage Classic / Irish Open, which includes PGA Tour, European Tour events and the Olympics. Players’ rankings are based on performance relative to the rest of the field:
- Top 25 SG Off The Tee: 1) Jon Rahm; 2) Bryson DeChambeau; 3) Scottie Scheffler; 4) Brooks Koepka; 5) Viktor Hovland; 6) Joaquin Niemann; 7) Patrick Cantlay; 8) Corey Conners / Justin Thomas; 10) Keith Mitchell; 11) Collin Morikawa; 12) K.H. Lee; 13) Sam Burns / Paul Casey / Tony Finau / Sungjae Im / Rory McIlroy / Phil Mickelson; 19) Sergio Garcia; 20) Louis Oosthuizen / Hudson Swafford; 22) Abraham Ancer / Sebastian Munoz / Carlos Ortiz; 25) Keegan Bradley / Max Homa / Hideki Matsuyama / Cameron Smith.
- Top 25 SG Approach: 1) Jon Rahm; 2) Shane Lowry; 3) Paul Casey; 4) Xander Schauffele; 5) Louis Oosthuizen; 6) Cameron Smith; 7) Keegan Bradley; 8) Daniel Berger; 9) Charley Hoffman; 10) Talor Gooch; 11) Sam Burns; 12) Russell Henley / Viktor Hovland; 14) Jhonattan Vegas; 15) Max Homa; 16) Hideki Matsuyama; 17) Abraham Ancer / Sebastian Munoz; 19) Cameron Tringale; 20) Corey Conners / Sungjae Im; 22) Marc Leishman / Collin Morikawa; 24) Joaquin Niemann / Scottie Scheffler / Justin Thomas.
- Top 25 SG Around The Green: 1) Jordan Spieth; 2) Cameron Smith; 3) Kevin Na; 4) 4) Patrick Cantlay / Si Woo Kim; 6) Harris English; 7) Matt Jones; 8) Harry Higgs; 9) Shane Lowry; 10) Ryan Palmer; 11) Keegan Bradley; 12) Billy Horschel / Joaquin Niemann; 14) Abraham Ancer; 15) Brian Harman / Brooks Koepka / Aaron Wise; 18) Sergio Garcia / Louis Oosthuizen; 20) Max Homa; 21) Patton Kizzire / Alex Noren / Carols Ortiz; 24) Russell Henley / K.H. Lee / Jhonattan Vegas.
- Top 25 SG Tee to Green: 1) Jon Rahm; 2) Cameron Smith; 3) Russell Henley; 4) Keegan Bradley / Justin Thomas; 6) Paul Casey / Louis Oosthuizen; 8) Patrick Cantlay; 9) Daniel Berger / Shane Lowry; 11) Kevin Na; 12) Sam Burns / Sebastian Munoz / Scottie Scheffler; 15) Xander Schauffele; 16) Joaquin Niemann; 17) Jhonattan Vegas; 18) Corey Conners; 19) Hideki Matsuyama; 20) Max Homa / Maverick McNealy; 22) Viktor Hovland / Sungjae Im; 24) Charley Hoffman / Collin Morikawa.
- Top 25 SG Putting: 1) Harris English; 2) Cameron Smith; 3) Cameron Tringale; 4) Tony Finau; 5) Mackenzie Hughes; 6) Abraham Ancer / Branden Grace; 8) Alex Noren; 9) Cameron Davis / Charley Hoffman / Ryan Palmer; 12) Sam Burns / Kevin Na / Joaquin Niemann; 15) Carlos Ortiz / Xander Schauffele; 17) Kevin Kisner / Lee Westwood; 19) Justin Thomas; 20) Stewart Cink; 21) Patrick Cantlay; 22) Dustin Johnson; 23) Viktor Hovland / Louis Oosthuizen / Harold Varner III / Jhonattan Vegas.
- Top 25 SG Total: 1) Jon Rahm; 2) Cameron Smith; 3) Kevin Na; 4) Louis Oosthuizen; 5) Sam Burns; 6) Justin Thomas; 7) Patrick Cantlay / Cameron Tringale; 9) Harris English; 10) Joaquin Niemann / Xander Schauffele; 12) Tony Finau / Charley Hoffman / Shane Lowry / Maverick McNealy; 16) Keegan Bradley; 17) Scottie Scheffler / Jhonattan Vegas; 19) Paul Casey / Russell Henley; 21) Alex Noren; 22) Abraham Ancer; 23) Sungjae Im; 24) Cameron Davis; 25) Viktor Hovland / Lee Westwood.
Path to Victory: Below are the end of round positions for the last 11 winners of this event:
- 2020 – Jon Rahm: Round 1: 51st, Round 2: 39th, Round 3: 6th.
- 2019 – Justin Thomas: Round 1: 1st, Round 2: 4th, Round 3: 1st.
- 2018 – Keegan Bradley: Round 1: 12th, Round 2: 3rd, Round 3: 6th.
- 2017 – Marc Leishman: Round 1: 1st, Round 2: 1st, Round 3: 1st.
- 2016 – Dustin Johnson: Round 1: 3rd, Round 2: 1st, Round 3: 1st.
- 2015 – Jason Day: Round 1: 1st, Round 2: 1st, Round 3: 1st.
- 2014 – Billy Horschel: Round 1: 4th, Round 2: 3rd, Round 3: 3rd.
- 2013 – Zach Johnson: Round 1: 2nd, Round 2: 3rd, Round 3: 4th.
- 2012 – Rory McIlroy: Round 1: 1st, Round 2: 2nd, Round 3: 3rd.
- 2011 – Justin Rose: Round 1: 1st, Round 2: 1st, Round 3: 1st.
- 2010 – Dustin Johnson: Round 1: 6th, Round 2: 4th, Round 3: 2nd.
Shots From the Lead: Below are the last 11 winners and where they were positioned in terms of shots from the lead during the tournament:
- 2020 – Jon Rahm: Round 1: 8 back, Round 2: 7 back, Round 3: 3 back.
- 2019 – Justin Thomas: Round 1: level, Round 2: 2 back, Round 3: 6 ahead.
- 2018 – Keegan Bradley: Round 1: 4 back, Round 2: 3 back, Round 3: 3 back.
- 2017 – Marc Leishman: Round 1: 2 ahead, Round 2: 3 ahead, Round 3: 5 ahead.
- 2016 – Dustin Johnson: Round 1: 2 back, Round 2: level, Round 3: 3 ahead.
- 2015 – Jason Day: Round 1: 4 ahead, Round 2: 5 ahead, Round 3: 6 ahead.
- 2014 – Billy Horschel: Round 1: 1 back, Round 2: 2 back, Round 3: 3 ahead.
- 2013 – Zach Johnson: Round 1: 1 back, Round 2: 3 back, Round 3: 3 back.
- 2012 – Rory McIlroy: Round 1: level, Round 2: 1 back, Round 3: 1 back.
- 2011 – Justin Rose: Round 1: 2 ahead, Round 2: level, Round 3: 4 ahead.
- 2010 – Dustin Johnson: Round 1: 4 back, Round 2: 2 back, Round 3: 1 back.
Incoming form of winners since 2010:
- Jon Rahm: 6th Northern Trust/13th PGA/52nd St Jude/1st Memorial.
- Justin Thomas: 12th Northern Trust/12th St Jude/11th Open/9th Scottish Open.
- Keegan Bradley: 49th Dell/34th Northern Trust/42nd PGA/4th Canadian Open.
- Marc Leishman: 3rd Dell Tech/MC Northern Trust/13th PGA/41st Bridgestone.
- Dustin Johnson: 8th Deutsche/18th Barclays/MC PGA/2nd Canadian Open.
- Jason Day: 12th Deutsche/1st Barclays/1st PGA/12th Bridgestone.
- Billy Horschel: 2nd Deutsche/ MC Barclays/47th Wyndham/59th PGA.
- Zach Johnson: 27th Deutsche/5th Wyndham/8th PGA/4th Bridgestone.
- Rory McIlroy: 1st Deutsche/24th Barclays/1st PGA/5th Bridgestone.
- Justin Rose: 68th Boston/6th Barclays/MC PGA/33rd Bridgestone.
- Dustin Johnson: 57th Deutsche/9th Barclays/5th PGA/15th Bridgestone.
First Round Leader Analysis: First round leader(s), their wave and winning score since 2019. Full First Round Leader stats are here.
- 2020 – Matsuyama – Group 22 – 3/67 – 40/1.
- 2019 – Kokrak/Thomas – Group 16/Group 7 -7/65 – 55/1 & 20/1.
- 2018 – McIlroy/Woods – Group 9/Group 2 -8/62 – 22/1 & 33/1.
- 2017 – Leishman – AM -9/62 – 40/1.
- 2016 – Castro – AM -7/65.
- 2015 – Day -10/61.
- 2014 – McIlroy/Spieth/Woodland -3/67.
- 2013 – Snedeker -8/63.
- 2012 – DeLaet/McIlroy/Simpson/Van Pelt -8/64.
- 2011 – Rose -8/63.
For the record, here’s the breakdown of pure Bentgrass green PGA Tour victors in the field since 2008:
- 7 – Rory McIlroy.
- 6 – Dustin Johnson.
- 5 – Jordan Spieth.
- 4 – Kevin Na, Webb Simpson, Justin Thomas.
- 3 – Patrick Cantlay, Bryson DeChambeau, Lucas Glover, Hideki Matsuyama, Phil Mickelson.
- 2 – Keegan Bradley, Stewart Cink, Sergio Garcia, Brian Harman, Chris Kirk, Marc Leishman, Xander Schauffele, Jhonattan Vegas.
- 1 – Daniel Berger, Cameron Champ, Tony Finau, Charley Hoffman, Billy Horschel, Kevin Kisner, K.H. Lee, Joaquin Niemann, Charl Schwartzel, Kevin Streelman.
The BMW Championship – now the second leg of the FedEx Cup Playoffs – has a number of trends that are intriguing.
In an event where the focus of the media and watching public is as to who will make it to the Tour Championship, recent champions are split down the middle when it comes to FEC starting position. Jon Rahm (9th in 2020), Justin Thomas (15th in 2019), Keegan Bradley (52nd in 2018), Marc Leishman (7th in 2017), Billy Horschel (20th in 2014), Zach Johnson (27th in 2013), Justin Rose (34th in 2011) and Dustin Johnson (16th in 2010) all arrived at the BMW with decent enough immediate form, however it didn’t directly translate to a top 5 FEC position. However the other 4 BMW champions since the Playoff structure was put in place back in 2009 have all been elite, in hot form and high in the FEC standings.
Tiger Woods in 2009 won his fifth title of the season, at 2/1, when ranked 2nd in the FEC standings. Jason Day and Rory McIlroy were both Number 1 in the FEC standings and had won previous Playoff tournaments at The Barclays and Deutsche Bank prior to winning the BMW at 15/2 and 7/1 respectively. And in 2016 Dustin Johnson, who had previously won the U.S. Open and Bridgestone Invitational, went on to win the BMW at 10/1 when ranked 3rd in the FEC standings.
Keegan Bradley broke a very strong trend 3 years ago, entering the BMW Championship with moderate direct form of 49th at the Deutsche Bank and 34th at the Northern Trust. Every other BMW winner in the Playoff era has had a top 11 finish within their past 2 Tour outings, and this really highlights this comment made by Nick Watney prior to the BMW in 2013, “Out of 70 guys, there’s kind of…there’s a big gap between guys playing really well, like you said, and guys struggling.”
The latest FedEx Cup Playoffs structure should now start to come into its own. We have cut 55 players from the original 125 qualifiers, so the top 70 move onto the second of 3 Playoff events. Many will be motivated to ensure that they qualify for the Tour Championship next week which opens the door to invitations to the 2022 Masters, U.S. Open and Open Championship. We had 6 players move into the top 70 last week, with 2 players – namely Charley Hoffman and Sungjae Im – breaking into the top 30 in the FedEx Cup standings.
Kevin Kisner (31st), Si Woo Kim (33rd), Marc Leishman (35th), Alex Noren (43rd), Sergio Garcia (44th), Lee Westwood (46th), Shane Lowry (47th), Webb Simpson (52nd), Paul Casey (54th) and Phil Mickelson (70th), all have work to do this week if they want a slice of the Tour Championship action next week.
For those higher up the rankings, things start to get serious this week. The Tour Championship sees a FedEx Cup Starting Strokes Index used, with the FedEx Cup standings leader starting the next week at -10, FEC Number 2 at -8, FEC Number 3 at -7, FEC Number 4 at -6 and Number 5 at -5. This then cascades down to those ranked 26th to 30th starting at Even. Previously at the Tour Championship, any player ranked 1-5 had the same chance of taking the overall FedEx Cup title by winning the title.
My selections are as follows: